Swaminathan Aiyar at PostGlobal

Swaminathan Aiyar

New Delhi, India

Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar is the Consulting Editor of The Economic Times, India's largest financial daily. He writes a popular weekly column, titled Swaminomics in the Times of India. He spends roughly half the year in New Delhi and half in Washington D.C., where he is a research fellow at the Cato Institute and an occasional consultant to the World Bank. He has been the editor of India's two main financial dailies, The Economic Times (1992-94) and Financial Express (1988-90). He was also the India Correspondent of the British weekly, The Economist, for most of two decades between 1976 and 1998. Close.

Swaminathan Aiyar

New Delhi, India

Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar is the Consulting Editor of The Economic Times, India's largest financial daily. He writes a popular weekly column in the Times of India titled Swaminomics. more »

Main Page | Swaminathan Aiyar Archives | PostGlobal Archives


Secularism on Shaky Footing

If Turkish women wearing headscarves can really make or break secularism, then it’s so weak it would have collapsed anyway.

» Back to full entry

All Comments (7)

Patricia Feeley:

Not when he's using my taxes to fund his trips, his phone, and lecturing the rest of us on morality. He ran on a platform of "purity" of spirit and being "a law and order" type. Well, it's against the law to use Tax money for illegal purposes. And, what he did was-in this State and in this Country against the law. He's welcome to move somewhere that he can say one thing and do another - he certainly has the wealth to go anywhere.

Basat Tayfun:

Hmm, I would rather live under a weak secular system for another 5 or 10 years than jump right into the endless pit of strong theocracy...

thishowiseeit:

A very wise person said: Religion is the opium of
the poor . If you keep the opium out of sight,
people will less likely get addicted. So, keep Religion out of sight!

Samir Saha, Sweden:

I fully agree with Mr Aiyar that if removing of headscarves ban means end of secularism, I must admit that it is based on falsehood and sham secularism. Over the past few decades, instead of the Turkish society being evolved into a modern secular and democratic entity, it has tragically ended into the quagmire of overt radicalization of Islam. This global syndrome in a very intriguing way started post 9/11 irrespective of the underlying pathologies of the tragedy itself. Now the question of head scarf could be explained in a variety of way. If it means a particular cultural trait in a harmless and very personal way independent of the propaganda of the state machinery, it´s probably OK. But if headscarf means isolation of our Muslim sisters from rest of the world, it is condemnable. If headscarf means "protection" from free world, it is condemnable. If headscarf means symbol of torture and domination it is condemnable.A personal dress code MUST never be linked to a national ideology or faith and certainly not go beyond the personal limits of choice. If it does, I do not see any difference between Nazi culture and the overtly Islamic trend that we are unfortunately observing across the continents. The question however must also be raised why an apparently secular country slipping into a dogmatic one. Why instead of Turkish govt lobbying for bringing Turkey within EU, they are lifting ban on headscarves? This move would make Turkey a difficult candidate for joining EU, I am afraid.

Anju Chandel, New Delhi:

We have to understand that 'Secularism' as practiced in India is very 'different' from the kind practiced in Turkey. India's secularism is 'inclusive' whereas the Turkish variety is 'exclusive'. Kemal Ataturk would have known very well the profound influence of Islam on its population and that could have been the prime reason for him to enforce a 'ban' on wearing headscarves by women.

And the way the nations with muslims in majority are increasingly getting sucked up in the whirlpool of radicalism, it would be no shock or surprise that tomorrow an otherwise 'secular' Turkey also votes for complete Islamicization of its political and social setup.

aha:

"then it’s so weak it would have collapsed anyway."

This is logic to support allowing the collapse of secularism in Turkey?

Symbols are important, how will the average Turk see this? Perhaps a sign of the lessening power of the military over the civilian government.

How will Turkey's Islamists see it though?

It appears Turkey is making it's choice as far as potential membership in the EU. Turkey is going the Arab way, and not the European way. It's their choice to make.

Good luck Turkey, you're going to need it.

ZB:

Part of the problem when discussing Turkish politics on the headscarf is the lack of differentiation between secularism as practiced in the US and India, and laicite. Turkish laicite, modeled after France, posits that religious symbols not be displayed in the political, hence public, space. "Laik" Turks feel that the founding principles of the country are being undermined by the changing of the constitution. Turkey, with or without the support of the whole public is moving away from laicite, hopefully towards secularism, rather than an Islamist state so many fear.

Post a comment

We encourage users to analyze, comment on and even challenge washingtonpost.com's articles, blogs, reviews and multimedia features.

User reviews and comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions.

Categories

PostGlobal is an interactive conversation on global issues moderated by Newsweek International Editor Fareed Zakaria and David Ignatius of The Washington Post. It is produced jointly by Newsweek and washingtonpost.com, as is On Faith, a conversation on religion. Please send your comments, questions and suggestions for PostGlobal to Lauren Keane, its producer.