how the world sees america

Upcoming Interview: Chellaney on India Nuclear Deal

What do you think about the U.S.-India nuclear deal: A golden opportunity? Hypocrisy? I'm meeting Professor Brahma Chellaney from India's Center for Policy Research tomorrow at 11:30am Delhi-time, 2am EST. When it comes to the India-U.S. nuclear deal, PG panelist MJ Akbar said he's the best guy to talk to.

Chellaney is a Member of the Policy Advisory Group headed by the Foreign Minister of India and has written a bunch of books on international security and arms control. In this article, India Has Sold Its Nuclear Soul to the U.S., he argues India is being duped by America. Check it out and post or email me any questions you'd like me to ask him.

Join Monthly Mailing List | | Digg | Facebook

Comments (7)


india doesnt sign the treaty because it divides the world into nuclear haves and have-nots?

amar- how does such reasoning play itself out?

whehter or not india signs it will have no bearing on the fact that the world is ALREADY divided into nuclear haves and have-nots.

india wants to be a have- and the article supplied is just a litany of complaints that india is not going to be GIVEN the same nuclear capability as the U.S.?

why would it
1) want that?
2) expect that?

how does holding itself to the same standards as other nuclear powers affect how the world is divided?

not signing the nuclear proliferation treaty, no matter how one tries to paint it a pretty color- it is what it is.

i have a hard time drumming up sympathy for the nuclear ambitions of india.

i have the same complaint that i do about the U.S.

take care of your people- solve your own problems-

bombs only have one purpose and it is not a noble one.

written last december from

~~~~~~~~Paradoxically, while Union Carbide is a wanted criminal in India, its owner Dow Chemical, with the blessing of the Indian government, planning a major expansion into the country. Perhaps its warm welcome has something to do with the fact that Dow arrives hand in hand with the American government. The US-India CEO Forum, held in March of this year (during the visit of George W. Bush to his new friend Prime Minister Manmohan Singh), included 25 top American executives. Among them was Andrew Liveris, CEO of Dow Chemical. The Bush tour ended with agreements to send nuclear power to India, mangoes to the US, and the release of a cheerful list of joint resolutions. The first item insisted on “welcoming the report of the US-India CEO Forum.” Other bullet points, painfully ironic considering the Bhopal issue reiterated commitments to "PREVENT the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction" and improve "capabilities to respond to disaster situations." It should be noted that the same methyl isocyanate gas that leaked in Bhopal was used as a chemical weapon against the Kurds by that exemplar of civic responsibility, Saddam Hussein.

Am i missing something?

if india has rushed into a bad deal out of greed for power and a desire to threaten or worse bomb it's neighbors, are we supposed to lament this?



my enemies enemy is my friend-

Israel has sold India two major weapons systems of particular importance. The first is Elta Electronics' Green Pine phased-array radar delivered in mid-2000, a key component of the controversial Arrow Ballistic Missile Defense system, which can detect incoming missiles from hundreds of kilometers away. Because the radar was developed without U.S. technology, Israel was able to sell it without U.S. permission. The second major deal, worth $1.1 billion, was the Phalcon Airborne Warning and Control System, which India plans to integrate with its Russian Il-76 heavy transport aircraft. This was a different matter altogether, because it was developed with U.S. technology, and Washington had blocked Israel's planned sale of the system to China in 1998. But after some debate, the United States, which was developing a new appreciation of India's strategic worth, approved Israel's sale of the Phalcon to India in 2003.

Several additional billion-dollar defense deals are in the works for the coming years, and they are likely to make Israel one of India's biggest arms suppliers, and India Israel's biggest market,and the first ever joint air force exercise is planned for later this year. Regular intelligence cooperation, anti-insurgency training and joint exercises are in place, and joint working groups on terrorism, technology and other areas have been organized.

4 years ago

Canadian Khalid Q Awan:

Dear Sir / Madam
I am 46 years old, Canadian citizen and native of Pakistan (Muslim). I was an immigration consultant in Canada and as part of my business; I had an office in New York.
During 2001 immediately after the Sept 11, event the US govt arrested me on Oct 25, 2001 on anonymous call, as a material witness for the 9/11 world trade centre terrorist attack. A detail investigation by the FBI and USA Naval intelligence dept was conducted and I was cleared, but even then govt put me in front of Grand jury, and I was cleared and the case was dismissed by the Grand jury of the US Federal Court.
Approximately after 2 weeks , before I was released from custody the US Govt imposed a new charges of Fraud and money laundering , under the advice of my attorney , I pleaded guilty and I was sentenced to prison for five years (which was four years more, what I pleaded). In which I had already spent 3 years in Detention jail, during the case , I had about 14 months left to finishing my sentence ,(instead of appealing, I preferred to applied for Treaty Transfer to Canada, because if the case is in the appeal, defendant is not eligible for transfer back to his home country).
While at prison, I learned from the case manager Miss House, that my citizen was incorrect in the FBOP’s (Federal Bureau of Prison) computer system as Pakistani instead of Canadian.
Its important to note , that all of my Canadian identifications (passport , citizenship card , S.I.N , Health card , Driving license etc) were under FBI’s possession, with a great deal of concern, I wrote a letter to the Canadian Consulate in Buffalo, N.Y to notify such mistake and requested them to fix this problem. This is especially important for Treaty Transfer back to Canada.
The Canadian Consulate official sent a letter to the jail to correct my citizenship status, however FBOP ignored the request and the citizenship status in the FBOP computer still reflect Pakistani instead of Canadian (Note: - I would be required to obtain visa to visit Pakistan) .In contrast, the deportation letter received from US Immigration dept, Contained the correct citizenship status of Canada.
At the hindsight, I believe that the FBOP intentionally left the citizenship as Pakistani, so that they could retained me at their facility, while the govt is planning to file new charges against me 3rd time.
Approximately six weeks before my released date on Jan 30, 2006 I was notified by the FBOP that I was being transferred from Ellenwood, PA to MDC (Metropolitan Detention Centre) in Brooklyn N.Y, it was explained to me, that the purpose of this transfer was in preparation for deportation back to Canada, (after few days, I signed the immigration deportation papers, with my consular Miss Chen).
But immediately after my arriving to MDC Brooklyn, I discovered during a phone call with my family in Montreal, that RCMP (Royal Canadian Mounted Police) official had contacted my sister and brother-in-law regarding the whereabouts of my wife and my current situation, there was no explanation given by the RCMP official to the purpose of the call and he left his phone number and asked my wife to call him back immediately, my wife called the RCMP official and left messages in his voice mail. Then the official contacted my brother-in-law again and had asked him to tell my wife not to call again, because there is nothing good nor anything bad.
Meanwhile the AUSA (United States Attorney) office Investigator and FBI brought me to their office to be interrogated without an attorney present, even AUSA told in the court to the judge on March 16, 2006 that he arranged attorney for me before my arrival from Ellenwood PA to MDC Brooklyn, N.Y, on Transcript; page 11, Transcript line No: 14 to 23.
AUSA: - He (Khalid Awan) was writ in the cause of a grand jury investigation. He clearly had criminal exposure. So to protect his interest I made an application to the duty magistrate for counsel to be appointed.
THE COURT: - Initially he was brought here by a Court to testify before the grand jury?
AUSA: - That is correct, Your Honour.

THE COURT: - When he arrived here, you made arrangements for an attorney to be pointed to request him?
AUSA: - Yes, Your Honour.
This interrogation started with the AUSA office Investigator stating that my family will be arrested in Canada if I refused to answer their questions.
At this point I am certain that my family is in great danger for reasons that I am not aware of. I was scared that my family would be harassed by these people along with the Canadian RCMP official; I strongly believe that the RCMP is doing this intentionally in collaboration with FBI official to further harass me to admit charges that I never committed.
Without knowledge of the reasons why the Canadian RCMP agency was involved. I was surprised that RCMP official directly approached my family instead of me without proper explanation, and its also shocked for me, that how RCMP got the phone number of my family (because before my arrest, I don’t have any single record in any police dept, of any country).
I was intimated and pushed to the edge during this interrogation; I was determined to provide anything these USA officials wanted to make them happy even is the questions made no sense, because I want them to stop the harassment to my family.
On March 15, 2006 I completed the term of my imprisonment and was to be released from American Custody and deported back to Canada. Before that I was arrested again 3rd time, and charged with providing “material support to a foreign terrorist” and money laundering (to an organization and person, which are not designated by the USA govt and belongs to Sikh religion).
These charges emerged while I was still in prison and without the capability of providing any type of support. It was even difficult for me to get enough financial assistance to pay legal fees. I could not have provided any material support while I was in prison for five years and I could not launder any money because I did not have any.
AUSA filed three counts of indictment against me.
Conspiracy to provide material support.
Provide a material support to the foreign terrorist.
Money laundering to support terrorism.
(Please note, that in my previous case govt charged me for money laundering and fraud from Jan 1999 to 2002 and “its mentioned in the plea-agreement by the AUSA that no further money laundering charges will be brought against defendant from Jan 1999 to April 2002” even then govt indict me for money laundering from 1998 to Nov 2001 (Which is double Jeopardy and violation of 5th Amendment of U.S Constitution.)
In Oct 2006, during pre-trial hearing on the motions filed by my attorney the first two counts of my indictment were dismissed by the judge, stating that there is a lack of facts and figures.
After two weeks AUSA re-indicted me again. I believe this is a desperate act of the AUSA to cover up a huge embarrassment. Further this hastily drawn indictment was full of factual errors and creative legal theories.
Since I was first arrested by the American govt, I believe that I have been singled out, isolated and discriminated against primarily because of my race and religion, in addition to the fact that I don’t know any information that the American govt is trying to pressure out of me.
I do not understand the American laws and this is what led to my pleading guilty in the first case. I have difficulty understanding the new charges also.
I have been charged under, section 2339(a) of Title 18 of the United States code, which makes it illegal to provide material support to a foreign terrorist.
Please understand, I am not a terrorist, I do not know any terrorist and I have had no connections with or to any known or unknown terrorist. I have been incarcerated for last 5 years and I had no money to provide or launder.
The law enforcement have in America is pressuring me to provide information to them that I really do not have or know. I am a Canadian Citizen and nearly all of my family is in Canada, including my wife and kids. I don’t know any information to tell them to help their investigation.
Because of this, I am being treated unfairly and my rights under the American constitution are being violated. I am being held here in further detention against my will for crimes which I could have never committed, because I was in prison.
I believe that I am a victim of the discrimination that was outlined in the July 3, 2006 issue of Time magazine (Page 29, column 3). In this article section 2339(a) & (b) are discussed and criticized “as most suspects are charged under these two sections. However, the justice dept here in America admits that of the more than 218 guilty pleas that it has obtained, most are for minor investigation issues that are uncovered deeding the course of their terrorism investigation. This suggest, according to the article that the Attorney General’s office have is not concerned about the rights or fairness or the manner in which it achieves convictions for the people they arrest. Furthermore, criticizes have noted that one of the patterns to emerge from these domestic prosecutions is that suspect seen too incompetent to carry out the deeds they are accused of. The Deputy Attorney General acknowledges that the Dept of Justice’s goal is “preventions through prosecutions” and this is done with no regard for an individual’s rights.
I agree that these guilty of terrorism should be prosecuted. But as the above mentioned article suggest, innocent people should not be targeted because of their race or religion.
I am not a terrorist and I should not be targeted and treated unfairly and unjustly.
I need your assistance desperately in my case, as I believe that I am being treated unjustly here. I would like to send you my attorney’s contact information and provide you with legal documents related to my case, so that you may become more familiar with my situation.
Please also note, that I appeared in the court , for no guilty of my 2nd superseding indictment on Aug 02, 2006 and on Aug 03, 2006 FBOP officials placed me in the SHU (Segregation Housing Unit) out of these months, I placed in the SHU isolation from Aug 03, 2006 to March 6, 2007 for unknown “Pending Investigation” in these 215 days of my segregation and isolation, I don’t have a single phone call access to my family, no legal calls to my attorney and Canadian Council, my legal mail opened in my absence, no medical treatment for my injured shoulder (even I went for hunger strike for 3 and half day) I harassed by the various jail officials and lot of other problems too which already been submitted in the attention of the FBOP higher authorities, but no action taken on them, after writing the court, instead of receiving the response or any action on my complaints, jail officials removed /moved me from MDC federal facility to Nassau County Jail .
My suffering has gone on for far too long, and I need your help to bring my suffering to an end. I want to return home to my family, because my imprisonment was injustice and will remain a great injustice forever.
May God bless you and be with you in your efforts to champion the cause of human rights, and the suffering of innocent prisoners and restore hope, faith and love to peoples all over the world.
FBOP NO. 50959-054

virtual reality: India:

I have seen all the wars in India from close range. The truth will never be known but it has been felt that America wants the simmering tension between India and her neighbors to stay alive and do business. All the wars have been expensive for India and she was really unprepared for any of them. What the Indians feel that there is no friend in a war- only spectators. Is it going to change? Is the world going to be more habitable? Peace is not cheap but the double edged politics makes all of us sick.


Fleur De Lys, I'm editing the video now. I got this question after I did the interview, but he did address it on many different planes. At root, he thinks disarmament is impossible. The question is about containing and securing nuclear weapons. India has long opposed NPT on the grounds that it divides the world into nuclear have and have-nots. So it never signed the treaty, though it does support some international treaty conventions. As far as Iran goes, Brahma says India should mediate between US and Iran, because India supports, in many cases, the rights of nations to nuclear technology, is opposed to a nuclear Iran, but also is opposed to an invaded Iran, which could further destabilize India's neighbors. Back to the post!

Fleur de Lys, Canada:

Where does India stand on world disarmament?


I'd be interested in getting a general overview of the deal and what it means for India' future. Not a very specific question i know but id like to know why india got it in the first place and what it really means

Post a comment

We encourage users to analyze, comment on and even challenge's articles, blogs, reviews and multimedia features.

User reviews and comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions.

PostGlobal is an interactive conversation on global issues moderated by Newsweek International Editor Fareed Zakaria and David Ignatius of The Washington Post. It is produced jointly by Newsweek and, as is On Faith, a conversation on religion. Please send your comments, questions and suggestions for PostGlobal to Lauren Keane, its editor and producer.