THE QUESTION
If India discovers that another Mumbai plot is on the way from Pakistan, what should it do? What right of unilateral self-defense should international law allow?
FROM THE PANEL
India's Greatest Ally: Pakistan
The two countries are ultimately an extension of one another and therefore must recognize that attacks and counterattacks will reverberate across their borders.
Posted by Vivian Salama USA/Middle East |Dec 16, 2008 at 5:07 PM
Pakistan's, and India's, Terror Trap
We must understand and appreciate that militant attacks of this sort are a problem for both India and Pakistan, and that dealing with them by more saber rattling will achieve nothing but tension.
Posted by Anwer Sher Dubai, UAE |Dec 15, 2008 at 7:19 PM
India's Options Are Limited
Whether justified or not, India shall be hard-pressed to adopt an American-style, "Bush Doctrine" posture of preemptive strikes against terrorists, or a policy of hitting back at any cost similar to adopted by Thatcherist Britain during the Falklands Episode.
Posted by Ali Ettefagh Tehran, Iran |Dec 15, 2008 at 6:40 PM
India's Rough Neighborhood
Every nation has the right for self-defense to deflect real threats coming from any other nation. India, however, knows that it cannot emulate America because Pakistan is not Iraq or Afghanistan.
Posted by Bashir Goth Somalia/UAE |Dec 15, 2008 at 3:04 PM
READER RESPONSE
Recent Discussions
- Should the World Help Iran Protesters?
- Iranian Election Aftermath
- Obama's Cairo Speech
- Has the World Lost Confidence in U.S. Economic Management?
- The Future of Newspapers
- U.S., Israel on a Crash Course Over Iran?
- Threats From An Interlinked World
- Reconciliation for Turkey and Armenia
- All Past Questions


Recent Comments
The carnage of Mumbai ...
India should be brave ...
PAW First of all, Ind...
World depression, perm...
Bob From the Washingt...
Tom, 20 minutes ago P...
its not pakistan but i...
TO ALL LET US PUT ASI...