THE QUESTION
The producers of the movie "The Kite Runner" had to evacuate three boy actors from Afghanistan because they were involved in a scene portraying homosexual rape. Who's at fault here: the movie producers who exposed the boys to danger, or the Afghan culture that threatens them?
Posted by David Ignatius and Lauren Keane on December 21, 2007 2:39 PM
FROM THE PANEL
Soli Ozel teaches at Istanbul Bilgi University's Department of International Relations and Political Science. He is a columnist for the national daily Sabah and is senior advisor to the chairman of theTurkish Industrialists' and Businessmen's Association. He is the editor of TUSIAD's magazine Private View and the editor of the Turkish edition of Foreign Policy a journal published by the Carnegie Endowment in the USA.
Why was there no outcry against the book’s author, since it was he who has produced the scene in his book?
Nikos Konstandaras is managing editor and a columnist of Kathimerini, the leading Greek morning daily. He is also the founding editor of Kathimerini’s English Edition, which is published as a supplement to The International Herald Tribune in Greece, Cyprus and Albania. He worked as a correspondent for The Associated Press from 1989 to 1997 before joining the Greek press and has reported from many countries in the region.
Filmmakers commenting on troubled societies have a particular responsibility to those who help them do so.
Mona Eltahawy is an award-winning syndicated columnist and an international lecturer on Arab and Muslim issues. Before she moved to the U.S. in 2000, she was a news reporter in the Middle East, including in Cairo and Jerusalem as a Reuters correspondent. She also reported from the region for Britain's The Guardian and U.S. News and World Report. She has lived in Egypt, the UK, Saudi Arabia, and Israel, and is currently based in New York.
Filmmakers left it to children to absorb the anger of those who hate self-criticism of any kind.
Yossi Melman is a senior commentator for the Israeli daily Haaretz. He specializes in intelligence, security, terrorism and strategic issues. An author of seven books on these topics, his most recent book, The Nuclear Sphinx of Tehran: Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and the State of Iran was published recently by Carroll & Graf.
As usual, a small group of religious zealots hijacks the debate – and intolerance wins.
Lamis Andoni is a Middle East consultant for Al Jazeera, the Qatar-based news station. She has been covering the Middle East for 20 years. She has reported for the Christian Science Monitor, the Financial Times and the main newspapers in Jordan. She was a professor at the Graduate School in UC Berkeley.
The scene was included for the sole purpose of further demonizing the Taliban - as if that is even necessary.
Originally from Pakistan, Anwer Sher is based in Dubai and writes for Gulf News, Khaleej Times and Emirates Today. His varied career experience includes banking, consulting, and real estate development. He has a Masters degree in International Relations.
Homosexuality isn’t new to Afghan culture, and the protesters are hypocrites. But Paramount should have known better.
Bashir Goth is a veteran journalist, freelance writer, the first Somali blogger and editor of a leading news website. He is also a regular contributor to major Middle Eastern and African newspapers and online journals.
Homosexuality is normal in the Muslim world until it enters public debate – then everyone jumps on the bandwagon to decry it.
Vivian Salama is an award winning reporter, producer and blogger. She has reported for various publications from across the Middle East, Sub-Saharan Africa, the Balkans, the United States and North and South Korea. She has also appeared as a commentator on the BBC, South African Broadcasting Corp., Iran's Press TV, NPR and as a reporter for Voice of America radio. A native of New York, Salama is currently based in Dubai where she reports for The National. Salama has an MA in Islamic Politics from Columbia University and she previously worked as a lecturer of international journalism at Rutgers University.
It is presumptuous for us to claim that certain practices in Afghanistan, or any other society, are wrong.
Recent Comments
oxcwerq vitucnkwa on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: xyrbq tlhm
adnan on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: ZAHER i ag
VICTORIA on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: well there
Yousuf Hashmi on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: The film i
Steven on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: All this d
MikeB on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: What happe
VICTORIA on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: to be clea
VICTORIA on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: zaher-
VICTORIA on 'The Kite Runner' - Who's to Blame?: THIS WEEK