THE QUESTION
On the 6Oth anniversary of the creation of India and Pakistan, this question: Was partition of the country in 1947 a mistake?
Posted by David Ignatius & Fareed Zakaria on August 22, 2007 12:24 AM
FROM THE PANEL
Vivian Salama is an award winning reporter, producer and blogger. She has reported for various publications from across the Middle East, Sub-Saharan Africa, the Balkans, the United States and North and South Korea. She has also appeared as a commentator on the BBC, South African Broadcasting Corp., Iran's Press TV, NPR and as a reporter for Voice of America radio. A native of New York, Salama is currently based in Dubai where she reports for The National. Salama has an MA in Islamic Politics from Columbia University and she previously worked as a lecturer of international journalism at Rutgers University.
Today's Mistakes Matter More Than Partition
There is no right or wrong answer to whether the 1947 partition of India and Pakistan was a mistake. Were mistakes made? Sure. Are mistakes still being made? Absolutely.
Vivian Salama USA/Middle East |Aug 22, 2007 at 12:53 PM
Saul Singer is Editorial Page Editor and author of the weekly column “Interesting Times” for the Jerusalem Post. He is the author of Confronting Jihad: Israel's Struggle and the World After 9/11. Before moving to Israel from the Washington area in 1994, Mr. Singer served for ten years as an advisor on the personal and committee staffs of the United States Congress, including the House Foreign Affairs Committee, Senate Banking Committee, and Senator Connie Mack.
An Israeli Perspective on Partition
In truth, a "successful" partition in 1947 would not have ended the conflict.
Saul Singer Jerusalem, Israel |Aug 22, 2007 at 12:45 PM
Ahmed Rashid, a Pakistani journalist based in Lahore, was the Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Central Asia correspondent for the Far Eastern Economic Review, for 22 years until the magazine was recently closed down. He presently writes for the Daily Telegraph in London, the International Herald Tribune, the New York Review of Books, BBC Online, The Nation, and academic and foreign affairs journals. He appears regularly on international TV and radio stations such as CNN and BBC World Service.
Put This Question to Rest
This is a favorite question of Western analysts but it's an absurd question because Partition is a fact of life and a fact of history now for millions of Indians and Pakistanis.
Ahmed Rashid Lahore, Pakistan |Aug 22, 2007 at 12:00 PM


Recent Comments
luckylucker on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: My favouri
vdnwbkcj ofsjey on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: vpxs taesi
vdnwbkcj ofsjey on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: vpxs taesi
vdnwbkcj ofsjey on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: vpxs taesi
onejsahw ewxgstvd on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: kgiqtf koy
onejsahw ewxgstvd on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: kgiqtf koy
kmvlo znfdb on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: pvfm qfad
xwehbna qlcakgd on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: eufchwpjx
xwehbna qlcakgd on Was It a Mistake to Partition India and Pakistan?: eufchwpjx