THE QUESTION
25 years from now, will historians write that Tony Blair was one of Britain's greatest modernizers or a promising leader who got stuck in a disastrous war?
FROM THE PANEL
The Anglo-Social Third Way
Perhaps not a great modernizer, but a good one who took advantage of a wide consensus in 1997 that Britain needed -- and could now afford -- to readjust the Thatcher reforms in a social democratic direction. Even the Conservative opposition has now accepted his reforms, which deserve the title of a "model" -- the Anglo-Social model.
London, England |May 17, 2007 at 10:33 AM
In on a Stallion, Out with Tail between Legs
Tony Blair cam into power like a hero, young and zealous to change the Labour Party and the world. He clicked with his equally savvy counterpart in the White House, Bill Clinton, But despite his robust reforms in the UK, his association with Clinton's successor turned him into a servile beast, devastatingly humiliated.
Bashir Goth Somalia/UAE |May 15, 2007 at 12:23 PM
Blair's Freedom Agenda -- Not China
As a former subject of Queen Elizabeth II, I view the UK through the prism of Hong Kong. Blair visited Hong Kong after it was returned from British to Chinese control, advocating stability and managed progress. While he preached freedom, democracy and human rights elsewhere, this somehow did not extend to China.
Kin-ming Liu Hong Kong |May 14, 2007 at 6:47 PM
Mixed Up in the Wrong Crowd
The West is about to lose the only formidable leader in the cohort of the past age. Tony Blair’s tragedy is that he has been surrounded by Jacques Chirac, Gerhard Schröder and George Bush -- the most disappointing team of Western leaders since World War II.
Thomas Kleine-Brockhoff Germany |May 14, 2007 at 3:06 PM
21st C. Churchill in Another Man's War
Tony Blair's legacy has many parallels to Britain's revered leader of World War II, Winston Churchill. But while Churchill sent British troops into battle to defend their homeland against Nazi invaders, Blair has sent his soldiers to die for a cause not their own. It is that of the friend who may bring his legacy down: George W. Bush.
Sami Moubayed Damascus, Syria |May 14, 2007 at 9:25 AM
Master of New Labour, Puppet in Iraq
It will not take 25 years before Tony Blair is recognized as the most imaginative and effective European political leader of his time. He has modernized the British Labour Party, forging a third way to reform our complex societies torn between welfare state and the requirements of globalization. But he also fell into a classic British trap.
Christine Ockrent Paris, France |May 14, 2007 at 9:13 AM
Style over Substance, Unfinished Plans
Tony Blair has managed to present himself as a flexible politician while choosing politics over policy. He promised to be a grand modernizer and many of his achievements are noteworthy. But the past 10 years have seen more media spin than effective reform; Britain has moved away from Europe and lost economic competitiveness.
Ali Ettefagh Tehran, Iran |May 14, 2007 at 8:35 AM
Passionate Believer in Humanity
I envy the Brits for having Tony Blair as their leader. Who could have believed that one day Protestant Rev. Ian Paisley and Catholic former terrorist Martin McGuinness would share a government after decades of bloodshed in Northern Ireland? Blair, one of the most impressive leaders of the 21st century, made it happen.
Yossi Melman Tel Aviv, Israel |May 14, 2007 at 8:01 AM
No Great Leaders, Only Great Times
I happen to think that there are no great leaders, only great times. And in great times, politicians and statesmen can lead effectively enough to earn the appreciation of posterity. Some luck is required to find oneself in power during great times, and some luck is needed to avoid making great mistakes.
Miklos Vamos Budapest, Hungary |May 14, 2007 at 7:19 AM
READER RESPONSE
Recent Discussions
Guest Voices
- There Are Two Pakistans
- Tsvangirai's Lawyer Meets His Own Fate
- Indonesia Loses Its Way
- Ireland Snubs the EU
- Ireland Takes the EU Spotlight
- Guest Voice Archives
Fareed Zakaria
» From the Moderator


Recent Comments
SIERRA LEONE PEOPLE’S ...
HUGO CHAVEZ INTERNATIO...
SIERRA LEONE PEOPLE’S ...
SIERRA LEONE PEO...
Hugo Chavez Internatio...
The Hugo Chavez Intern...
SIERRA LEONE PEOPLE'S ...
Sierra Leone People’s ...