THE QUESTION
There are two kinds of land mines: the kind that explodes when you step on it, and the kind that explodes when you take your foot off. Which kind is Iraq? How can it be defused?
FROM THE PANEL
Neighbors Won’t Step Up Until U.S. Gone
The situation in Iraq will eventually be resolved by Iraqis, but the presence of Americans will delay any serious attempts at a solution. American occupation remains the strongest argument for armed opposition, as well as the first excuse why other countries in the region don't help Iraq out.
Posted by Daoud Kuttab Jerusalem/Amman, Jordan |May 4, 2007 at 4:33 PM
Lose-Lose Situation, Start Cutting Deals
In Iraq, the U.S. faces a choice between bad and worse. It would be a mistake to stay for long, but leaving could devastate the region's delicate political composition. To stabilize the situation, the U.S. needs the help of Syria and Iran. There's no alternative to talking.
Posted by Yossi Melman Tel Aviv, Israel |May 3, 2007 at 10:43 AM
Baghdad Walls No Vision for Future
The U.S. strategy has been focused on "security" -- stopping armed attacks against its forces and the Iraqi government. But setting up barriers around Sunni neighborhoods will only promote sectarianism and legitimize armed opposition groups. The U.S. does not have a clear vision of how to end the occupation and provide a future for all Iraqis.
Posted by Lamis Andoni Doha, Qatar |May 2, 2007 at 12:02 PM
America, It's Your Baby
The consequences of the U.S. leaving Iraq too soon would be devastating. But the question is not just a practical one, it is a moral one. A majority of Americans supported the Iraq war; now they are responsible for what happens in Iraq. Or they can never again claim the moral high ground anywhere in the world.
Posted by Michael Young Beirut, Lebanon |May 2, 2007 at 9:29 AM
Destroy is Easy, Win takes Patience
Try this analogy: the American tortoise racing a terrorist hare. Terrorists have an advantage in that it is easier to destroy than to build and preserve, but destruction loses support over time. The terrorists' only hope of winning in Iraq is for the U.S. to lose the will to keep going -- slow but steady.
Posted by Saul Singer Jerusalem, Israel |May 1, 2007 at 4:42 PM
Digging the Iraq Hole Deeper
A better analogy would be the hole-digging one: when you're sinking into a deepening hole and you need to stabilize the situation, stop digging. More troops cannot produce a peaceful Iraq, only a government that Iraqis see as legitimate can.
Posted by Rami G. Khouri Beirut, Lebanon |Apr 30, 2007 at 3:16 PM
If Leave, Regional War and "Shiastan"
Four years ago, George W. Bush opened Pandora’s Box. And now there is no realistic way to put the lid back on. The Iraq war was a mistake, but leaving now would be far more costly than staying. There would certainly be regional war.
Posted by Leon Krauze Mexico |Apr 30, 2007 at 10:31 AM
Occupation Only Lights More Fuses
Brilliant proposition, but there is a third “mine” – undermine. George Bush has undermined the American people with the number of fuses he has lit in the Middle East. If the Iraq mine explodes when the foot comes off, that's better than staying to light more fuses.
Posted by M.J. Akbar India |Apr 30, 2007 at 9:47 AM
America Waltzing in a Minefield
The situation in Iraq is not simply a matter of invasion without conquest, a failing puppet state. Iraq was already a minefield, and the invasion’s waltz of quickstep missions turned that minefield into a very complex disaster zone.
Posted by Ali Ettefagh Tehran, Iran |Apr 30, 2007 at 9:05 AM
READER RESPONSE
Recent Discussions
- Should the World Help Iran Protesters?
- Iranian Election Aftermath
- Obama's Cairo Speech
- Has the World Lost Confidence in U.S. Economic Management?
- The Future of Newspapers
- U.S., Israel on a Crash Course Over Iran?
- Threats From An Interlinked World
- Reconciliation for Turkey and Armenia
- All Past Questions


Recent Comments
The problem with this ...
Yes BobL, You are righ...
Tom, Grenada it is. ...
BobL The reality is...
BobL With the mood ...
Tom Wonacott, You wro...
Salamon "...When re...
To Jrlr from Daniel. Y...