I've often remarked that every pope needs a good editor. Most papal encyclicals are too long and the typical papal message is often too wordy and sometimes short on clarity.
When Pope Benedict XVI quoted an obscure source at Regensburg making an unfavorable comment about Islam, he should, if indeed he thought it necessary to offer the quote in the first place, have dissociated himself from that statement in unambiguous terms--"I don't, of course, agree with that at all. I find it offensive and understand how it might offend Muslims today."
A good editor might have suggested that. And Benedict could have offered the statement as an example of how not to get a needed discussion about the relationship of faith and reason off the ground.
But how now can he and the Christian church in general encourage Muslims to face up to their more violent and extreme factions? Very gently, very carefully.
He and those whose eyes and ears are at his service should be on the alert for any positive and irenic gesture or statement from any Islamic source and be quick to applaud it. Circumstances might require quiet applause in a given case, but awareness of some breaking development in the world of Islam that is worthy of applause will mean heightened sensitivity in the Christian world to what is good in Islam.
Being poised to praise is a much more desirable posture for Christian leaders, over against Islam, than being ready to condemn.
Please e-mail On Faith if you'd like to receive an email notification when On Faith sends out a new question.
Email Me | Del.icio.us | Digg | Facebook


