An Instant Classic in American Civil Religion
The speech Mitt Romney just delivered is in my view an instant classic in American civil religion.
One of the troubling shifts in America’s self-conception over the last generation is not so much our drift toward God as our drift away from worry over the possibility that God might not be all that pleased with us. What made Lincoln great was his confusion about God’s purposes, his awareness that providence was in the last analysis (and perhaps even in the first) inscrutable. What makes so many contemporary American leaders small is their conviction that, come what may, God is on our side, which is to say that we lord over God rather than the other way around.

