Our Unjust War Leaves A Mess To Clean Up
Traditional "just war" teaching had its origins when the early church rejected the pagan notion that the gods of war require us to go all out in defeating our enemies.
Traditional "just war" teaching had its origins when the early church rejected the pagan notion that the gods of war require us to go all out in defeating our enemies.
On one level, dealing with a public offense--at least one that falls short of a criminal act--can be a fairly straightforward matter. Someone like Imus issues a formal apology, and those whom he offended then say that they "accept" this apology. That happens a lot, and it is a perfectly reasonable public transaction.
But has Imus genuinely repented? And have the Rutgers team members really forgiven him? In each case I have my doubts.
You certainly don’t have to be religious to acknowledge that there are moral boundaries that a physician should not cross in responding to a patient’s needs and wishes. And for the believer--Christian, Jewish, Muslim, for example--those boundaries will be reinforced by strong religious convictions. There are some things that God forbids us to do.
But this is not simply a case of religious obligations versus the obligation to serve patients. For the believer, serving a patient is itself a matter of religious conviction. In Christianity, for example, physical healing is one of the things we are called by God to promote. Jesus devoted a lot of attention in his earthly ministry to responding to genuine physical needs.
It is not enough, then, for a physician simply to say “No” to a certain expressed need or wish--or more generally, to refuse to engage in a certain kind of practice or procedure. Even in saying “No,” the obligation to be a healer does not disappear. If, for example, certain Christian communities insist that physicians should not perform abortions, they--along with the physicians in their midst--have a religious obligation to provide alternative ministries of healing, compassion and support for people who in their own lives see abortion as the only solution.
For those of us who claim to be servants of the One whom we refer to as “the Great Physician,” saying “No” to a specific practice or procedure does not cancel our obligation to work for the well-being of people who need healing and comfort.
What makes the deadly sins bad is that they are excessively self-centered versions of something good. Rest is an important part of life, for example, but slothful people greatly overdo it. We need to eat in order to live, but gluttony takes eating to an excess.
So what about greed? There is nothing wrong with wanting things, or with the motivation to make a profit. If no one ever wanted to excel by outwitting someone else, we would not have chess games or spelling bees!
What Islam Really Says About Violence, Rights and Other Religions
Gomaa, Fadlallah, Mubarak, Khan, Siddiqi, Ellison, others | On Faith