Now or Later?
This sounds like such a (specifically Protestant) “Christian” question! Which means that I have to imagine the answer. Isn’t “being saved” forever, but “good works” only for the time being, i.e.,here, now, on planet earth?
If so, then the calculus is self-evident: forever is a longer time. On the other hand, were this question being asked from a right-here-right-now perspective, the person holding to the second option listed would definitely make the better neighbor.

