Matt Maher
Catholic musician, recording artist

Matt Maher

Maher is a recording artist on Essential Records. A Catholic musician originally from Newfoundland, Canada, he later relocated to the Phoenix area of Arizona.

 ALL POSTS

Will Obama Seek the Truth?

What did you think of President Obama's commencement speech Sunday at Notre Dame? How will the Notre Dame controversy change the abortion debate in America?

There are two issues at hand here - one is the significance of President Obama's speech on the campus of Notre Dame; the other, a larger need for a new conversation about truth.

The truth being revealed here is that an institution once considered a place that upheld Christian principles of love, truth, humility, and purpose has been slowly replaced by a corporation with a board of directors that upholds different value systems. This is systemic of most major Catholic post-secondary institutions; faith is now a secondary focus; it is not that which drives the call to academic excellence, fraternal growth, and the development of one's character - first as a child of God, and secondly as a member of society; now, faith is merely window dressing.

Maybe what is needed is not grandstanding and loud protest, but humble consideration by all Bishops and religious educational institutions as to why our schools are going the way of the rest of the world.

The second issue, that of the President's words - well, to be honest, I fail to see the significance other than grandstanding. There are many things that a guest speaker for commencement could talk about, and for the President to choose to talk about abortion at a Catholic university - is salt in a wound. If the President is serious, he would invite top religious leaders, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, as well as top leaders from the evangelical church to Washington for a real debate - of ethics, philosophy, and morality; to look with empirical eyes at the issue of life - not just abortion, but of our collective respect (or disrespect) for human life.

I believe, as now a recent Gallup Poll suggests, that 51 percent of our country's population is ready to look at this issue - not in a spirit of hatred and condemnation - but in a quest for the truth. This to me is a real step in the right direction; not just restating the obvious - that every human life, regardless of creed, color, or socio-political stance, deserves to be treated with dignity and respect.

By Matt Maher  |  May 20, 2009; 1:04 PM ET
Share This: Technorati talk bubble Technorati | Del.icio.us | Digg | Facebook
Previous: President Obama Deserved Respect, Not Applause | Next: Cheney, Torture and the Road to Hell

Comments

Please report offensive comments below.



What seems to have been lost in the controversy are the key elements of the issue President Obama was not invited to participate in a debate or dialogue of fair minded people which would have been perfectly acceptable for a Catholic university since debate is a valuable learning tool G.K.Chesterton took on Clarence Darrow in a series of debates The Church has courageous defenders who could espouse the Church's teaching effectively and respond to any criticism and doubts raised in objection to Her teaching .
Instead Notre Dame awards an honorary degree to the President .Again not harmful in itself because university honour degrees are often awarded to public figures who have contributed to society in a significant way. If an honorary degree was awarded to President Obama for improving Afro-American standing in the wider community or for political acumen it would have been credible but to award the President who has openly espoused and continues to flag his unstinting support for the pro "Choice" campaign is a gross betrayal of Truth.
The President's speech was soothing, charming and I imagine very appealing to the young people he addressed He pressed all the right buttons I only hope they do take to heart his urging them to protect God's creation by rallying to vote for and support those who have been fighting to protect the greatest of God's creation the human person.
The President himself said at the
Washinton Prayer breakfast Feb 2009
"But no matter what we choose to believe, let us remember that there is no religion whose central tenet is hate. There is no God who condones taking the life of an innocent human being. This much we know."
How does he reconcile this statement with his support of pro abortion funding in Congress and other pro abortion measures he has supported?


Posted by: marymack77 | May 26, 2009 2:21 AM
Report Offensive Comment

I'm not sure whether the President had the choice honestly to skip the subject in his speech. It was made front and center by those who vocally protested in the days and weeks between the announcement of his invitation and the day itself. How could this President, or any other ignore the questions being raised?

One of the strengths of our current President is his willingness to model the very adult behavior that we need to exhibit as a presupposition for fruitful dialogue. It is this sort of modeling that makes possible, I believe, the very Gallup Poll findings you cite.

During the early years of the buildup to, and fighting in, Iraq, the administration brooked no debate. The Roman Catholic Bishops, led by the Pope himself, as well as his own Methodist church leadership spoke out against the war, and the only response from the President was essentially "I've decided." For the past eight years, the images I remember are "I'm the decider." "Mission accomplished" while dressed in a fighter pilot's "poopy suit" and swaggering across the flight deck. "Bring it on". On the subject of abortion, his answers were "No". That fits the Catholic Bishop's statements on the subject, but it hardly gives a place to try and help people of all beliefs on the topic find a way as a nation to reach some sort of understanding (and I realize that for the most strongly anti-abortion held beliefs, there IS no way other than agreement...but there are a huge number of other people who are very uncomfortable with this stance...even as many of us find abortion, at the very least, undesirable. How can those whose position is "No" and the rest of us reach a point of civility, at least, on this issue?)

What a refreshing model at Notre Dame. Instead of cockiness, President Obama explained many of the dimensions of he issue as he sees them, and invited dialogue on the subject. Isn't that what we want in the way of leadership?

I admire Notre Dame for not backing down, thereby providing a beginning on this subject, and I believe that at the end of his term will mark some growth on this subject.

Pr Chris

Posted by: CalSailor | May 23, 2009 1:30 AM
Report Offensive Comment

The comments to this entry are closed.

 
RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2009 The Washington Post Company