Muslims Speak Out
Merve Kavakci

Merve Kavakci

Former Turkish Politician

Dr. Merve Kavacki is an outspoken critic of Turkey’s secularization policy, traveling the globe in support of Muslim women’s rights, especially to the hijab. Details

Main Page | All Entries | About This Project | Muslims Speak Out Archives | xml RSS Feed

Merve Kavakci

1. The word Jihad comes from the word jahd. It literally means striving and spending utmost effort to do something. Jihad can be interpreted in different ways depending on the context. It does not necessarily mean “war” according to Quran, Hadith and Islamic legalities. It also means inner development of a person, controlling evil faculties one may have as anger, jealousy and phobia. It would not be correct to argue that Islam, as a rule of thumb, sanctions the use of violence. It permits however a defensive war which is based on just cause (war) against an offensively waged aggression.

Considering that suicide bombing issue is de facto and is not de jure Islamic, I would argue that one has to reach the hearts and minds of the people, conquer the minds and hearts of the “other side” from within as evidence suggested by the life of the Prophet Muhammad. As it is well known, when he was stoned in Taif, he said oh my God grant them guidance them, they don’t know, instead of reacting violently.

On this note, I believe that it is crucial to look into the sources of such acts in-depth. A question such as why such actions did not exist, for instance, two centuries ago, must be pondered upon within this context.

2. The Arabic term irtidad (apostasy) comes from redd which means rejection in this context. Rejection of faith in Islam means rejecting the Word (Kalima) which contains two elements: Oneness of God (La ilaha illallah) and believing in the messenger-hood of Muhammad (Muhammadun Rasullullah). A muslim’s rejection of one or both of these principles renders murtadd (apostate). According to classical Islamic literature, a Muslim is not granted de jure Islamic right to convert to another faith in public as opposed to in heart and in private. This is predicated upon the fact that Islamic jurisprudence credo is considered to be a part of the theoretical public order in an Islamic state.

One may think that blasphemy and apostasy in public against the public order theoretically may fall outside the application of “La ikraha fi-Deen.”

3. In Islam men and women are both created by the same God. Both are equal addressees of God. They are both charged with duties and obligations. They are also granted rights. From the point of creation, men and women are created equal. However they are assigned different functions based on their physical characteristics. Women, in this context, have independently as the addressee of God, have all rights granted by Allah and obligation charged by Allah. Right to Property ownership, right to have business, right to privacy both in public and private spheres with the privileges defined for women such as to bear child, to be mother are among such rights as opposed to men’s reciprocal rights and duties.

One should not make a comparison between women’s rights in Islam and rights in the western world. For, they are not comparable to one another. Women’s rights in Islam, for example, cannot be evaluated within the context of liberal societies which promote limitless exercise of freedom on women’s bodies such as extra marital relations. Islam is a family and community oriented religion. Limitless exercise of freedom is perceived as detrimental to family structure and community welfare. Objectification of male or female body is not acceptable in Islam as well. What is considered as a “right” in the Western context can very well be seen as a liability in the Islamic societies: For instance, a Muslim woman does not have to work if she chooses to. That is to say that it is the male’s responsibility to be the bread winner for the family. If the woman chooses to work, then the husband has no right to claim the earnings of the wife. In other words, the absence of the “right” in the Western context is a “privilege” in the Islamic context.

Reader Response

ALL COMMENTS (34)

Post a comment

On Faith is an interactive conversation on religion moderated by Newsweek Editor Jon Meacham and Sally Quinn of The Washington Post. It is produced jointly by Newsweek and washingtonpost.com, as is PostGlobal, a conversation on international affairs. Please send your comments, questions and suggestions for On Faith to David Waters, its producer.