Britney and Us
We are overwhelmed in our time by images of suffering from far away -- devastation unfolding in real time in digital resolution and Dolby sound, lives being ruined before our eyes -- that we don't know what to do with, how to live with. It's a kind of relief to turn to another genre of dramatic images that bombard us: the lives of celebrities, people who by contrast "have it all." We can admire their excess of beauty and revelry and love affairs and then, when their marriages end or they head into treatment, we can follow their plight knowing that they require nothing of us, not even guilt. They have all the resources for all the solutions in the world.
All this is by way of saying that I don't worry overly about our cultural interest in celebrities per se. I understand and participate in it and suspect it is as old as time. But as I've watched Britney Spears unravel before our eyes, in real time, with no end in sight, I have begun to think it's time for a pause, a moment of cultural soul-searching. I've been disturbed by the numerous reports I've heard - not in People or Us but in major news outlets - gleefully tallying all the money she continues to make for paparazzi and other people around her, noting with amusement that the profits only rise as she sinks to ever-lower depths.
A few years ago I had a conversation with Pankaj Mishra, an Indian journalist who traced the Buddha's legacy in history and across the world as a social thinker. Mishra himself is an intellectual and a skeptic and came to an interest in religion warily and indirectly. But when I pressed him about the rise of Buddhism and other contemplative religious practices in Hollywood in recent years, he refused to be critical. Stars, he said, have achieved the fame and wealth that our culture exalts and decrees as the pinnacle of success. Yet they discover, each in their own private places and struggles, that fame and wealth can accompany an utter void of meaning. Outward glory does not equal, and may in fact thwart, personal happiness. This simple insight, too, is as old as time.
Britney Spears, as much as any other current celebrity, is our creation. She achieved stardom at an age when her sense of self, of what is good and right and meaningful in life, was completely determined by the adults and the culture around her. But the same machine that made her is exquisitely calibrated to destroy and discard her.
So though it might seem a stretch to add Britney's plight to our public list of "moral values" issues, I'm proposing that she might belong there. I'd like to hear religious and spiritual leaders bold enough to call for compassion and introspection. I wonder who or what could effect a stop to the paparazzi hounding of an already ruined person? Where are the voices genuinely concerned about the plight of her children, whose own personal devastation is also on display in real time, a matter of public spectacle through no fault of their own? What is it doing to our own children when we fail to think and speak about our collective complicity in the creation and downfall of a human being like Britney Spears?
When I write about why religion matters and how to talk about it, I am describing my own longing that diverse religious, ethical, spiritual and theological voices in our culture could gain a new weight and wisdom beyond the tired and polarizing issues - even and precisely in situations like this.
Krista Tippett is creator and host of Speaking of Faith at American Public Media. Her program is heard on over 200 public radio stations across the U.S. and globally via podcast. She is author of "Speaking of Faith - Why Religion Matters and How to Talk about it."
By Krista Tippett |
March 14, 2008; 10:38 AM ET
Share: Email a Friend |
Technorati
| Del.icio.us | Digg | Facebook
Previous: The Religious Counterculture |
Next: Take This (Portuguese) Bread
Posted by: jim filyaw | March 18, 2008 12:26 AM
Report Offensive Comment
Britney isn't one of my ancestors, isn't one of my descendents, and isn't likely to become my wife, concubine, or mistress.
She has the money necessary for her food, lodging, clothing, clean air and water, and recreation for the rest of her life; and isn't likely to hire me for any of those.
So why should I, or anyone else in my position, give a darn about Britney when there are far more important things in our lives to do something about?
Posted by: Micha El | March 17, 2008 3:16 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Friends of The NATION OF ISLAM U.S.A.:
"ON-WOMANS-WRONGS & SHAME, not RIGHTS!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=peFQWuk4nuo&feature=related
UNDERCOVER MOSQUE! THOUSANDS INVOLVED!
Abolish islam in Sweet Sweet U.S.A.!
Remove Tax free Status & Building permitts etc..!
Posted by: Anonymous | March 17, 2008 8:48 AM
Report Offensive Comment
There is often a wild puppy in every litter. Britney was born with genes that make her as she is. You could say is a mental illness. She must have some talent(s) as she sell CDs and entrance to concerts. Could her misbeaving been prevented by different upbringing? probably no. Can be treated? Probably not. Should be stop reading about her? Many just speedreading about her in 5 seconds., and is a conversation suject.
Posted by: thishowiseeit | March 16, 2008 8:28 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Thanks, Krista, for addressing this sad situation and calling on others, particularly religious leaders, to demand an end to the circus hovering around this tragedy. Who has the courage, heart, moral standing, and authority to confront the media vultures who profit from such human tragedies, and more importantly, who has the courage to confront a society without compassion and humanity about what we've become?
The situation seems destined to end in a young mother's demise, unless someone with her best interests at heart and some intelligence and maturity (is there anyone like that close to Britney Spears?) takes control of the situation and protects this young woman and gets her the help she needs.
It's sad indeed to see what celebrity does to young stars, and sadder still that even her parents seem utterly incapable of providing the right kind of support for their daughter. We have not just one lost generation, but successive lost generations that are becoming the "norm" in our society.
Posted by: kimberly in new hampshire | March 15, 2008 10:10 PM
Report Offensive Comment
i guess after reading your morally vacuous assertation on what are some the true ills of our world i find myself appalled. i have to ask the questiion did somebody pay you to actually plant this story so we wouldlnt actually think about the miserery we are actually causing by starting an unjust war on the back of lies so a few men could make a little more money and get a little bit of power. or that idiots are actually borrowing money from china to cut taxes and morgaging ing our countries future.in truth i suspect britney spears is far more lucid than you appear to be. How can with all the real moral issues in the world you choose britaney to pummel instead of the neo cons and the right wing war hawks and the social preditors who contiue to spill thier filth freely with no inspection. i challenge to open your eys and pick something that truely would make a differenence in the world or quit taking up space that other people could use far better than you have.. have you ever actually studied the bible? i thought not o....or perhaps you have forgotten what i actually says.....
Posted by: artistkvip1 | March 15, 2008 4:52 PM
Report Offensive Comment
I agree totally. And I would add that the Britney fascination has been especially disappointing because it shows the depth of the public's lack of understanding when it comes to mental illness. I don't know exactly what Britney's been diagnosed with, as that info is still private, but it's clearly a medical condition. To see all the schautenfruede society takes from watching a young woman struggle with mental illness.... It's really disheartening, to say the least. We don't need another example of the stigma faced by those suffering depression, anxiety, bi-polarity, etc., and I don't imagine the mockery aimed at Britney is making life any easier for the millions of other people with similar problems.
Posted by: Rachel | March 15, 2008 3:34 PM
Report Offensive Comment
What's a Britney?
And is it of any consequence or importance?
Posted by: Norrie Hoyt | March 15, 2008 2:33 PM
Report Offensive Comment
I too have been fascinated with the fascination.
I have thought of the Romans controlling the public by offering them the spectacles in the Coliseum; of the way some people need
reassurance that they are better than others, and gain it by gloating over the suffering of others. I have thought of the somewhat sexual charge that Brit-xploitation carries, and been reminded
of those excitedly taking cell-phone shots of the young woman being stoned to death, in her naked anguish.
What is it? the dark side of all of us, and the complicity between us and those who give access
to exploring that darkness, while it lives safely in the experience of another.
We can, through watching Britney and those like her, have a whole range of emotions that in our own lives would cause shame or discomfort; but in the lives of others, are our potluck contributions to water-cooler camaraderie.
We have so many complicit inner agreements: we shun paparazzi and hunt for their photos; we preach virginity and buy Penthouse; we affect morality and cheat on our taxes. Gov Spitzer is our poster child.
So when someone holds up that dark side for public view, especially a juicy woman who used to be a sweet girl, it is an irresistible chance
to look, even while clucking in dismay.
In the oddest way, it reassures us that we are ok, even while we can feel the stirring of something dark inside ourselves, are are uncertain as to that stirring's origins. Even the sympathy we feel buttresses our need to believe in our own goodness.
Some cultures say, there is no long with our short, no hot without cold. Seeing someone
we can position below us gives us a sense of altitude. Of course, once we feel really safe,
perhaps our hearts can truly open in compassion
for not only those 'below' us, but also for ourselves and our own needs.
T. Lhamo
Posted by: Tenzin Lhamo | March 15, 2008 9:30 AM
Report Offensive Comment
Att, Att;
Dear Islamics via their ELDERS OF 'Al TAQIYA" (Islamic-ZIONIOSTS, not Jews or Hindu's et al, in WAHABi SAUDI et al are atempting to take over the World with their Cartoon Pretex's which is the Islamic Stratagy to incite etc.. as MOHAMAD instructs them....)
Please tell the world that Islam Was Wrong To Attack USA via World Trade Center(s), Pentagon & Almost White-House etc..!!!!
Shame Shame Islam!
Posted by: Anonymous | March 15, 2008 12:51 AM
Report Offensive Comment
PEACE-PAZ-SHOLOM-SALAM-AHiMSA & in ALL Creature Languges; LOVE Hugg's n Kiss's, 'Dor a me La .. Te...'
Thanka Shame!
Posted by: Anonymous | March 14, 2008 2:15 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Remember: We are in "ETERNiTY AVOiDiNG LONLiNESS", JUSTLY for a TiME (in TEMPERATURE not Clock) in a carbon based, "Bio-Finite" frontal lobe carrying , immortal HEURISTIC/a/o.....
Posted by: Anonymous | March 14, 2008 2:10 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Please Visit from time to TiME. Thanka Shame!
J [JO][ZE][VZ][.US].
O
Z
E
V
Z.US
Posted by: Anonymous | March 14, 2008 2:01 PM
Report Offensive Comment
J
O
Z
V
Z
.
U
S
J
O
Z
E
V
Z
.
U
S
Posted by: Anonymous | March 14, 2008 1:47 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Oh what a peaceful morning !
On aljazeera today, they say,
The top story is perhaps the collapse
Of a three-storey-
Building in Beijing;
The next biggest news on BBC NEWS
Is about Madonna whose daughter's gonna
Meet the man who deflowered her;
And then there’s the story of the glory
Of Africa, which, they say, today,
Will be purchased by Bill Gates
And will be prosperous
And its story wonderous.
No wars today on aljazeera
No terror today on aljazeera
For the world is now more peaceful
Without Saddam & Zarkawi
With only Karzay & Badawi
With only Chris Finch & David Lynch
And King US President
On top of the World!
Posted by: Nasamat | March 14, 2008 1:12 PM
Report Offensive Comment
The comments to this entry are closed.












i confess that i read 'people' magazine only when stuck in an overbooked dentist office. brain cells are too important to be wasted. but, try as i might, i can't deny an awareness of the brittany phenomenom. i'd be prouder of knowing the sexual history of titus oakes, but everyone gets stuck in supermarket check out lines, don't they?
my observation: what she has would be worse than the curse of midas. can you imagine? having wealth, beauty, and celebrity visited upon you before you're old enough to vote? the downside: in a presumably long life, its all down hill from here. nothing in her character, intelligence, talent, or common sense bodes that she might ever again attain the heights where she is now.
enjoy your fifteen minutes, kid.