United States of immigrants
Today's guest blogger is Ilana Alazzeh, who was born in San Francisco to an Israeli mother and Palestinian father. She currently attends Smith College in Massachusetts, where she stays active in community service and interfaith work.
An instructor and I were talking after class earlier this year. The conversation was going great until she asked, "So what foreign country did you say you were from again?" I tried not to laugh and ended up saying "California", the place of my birth, instead of Washington, D.C., where I graduated high school, to minimize her embarrassment and maximize the distance from where we were standing in Massachusetts.
Conversations like this happen a lot in my life. My instructor meant no harm, but coupled with other life incidents of discrimination including verbal abuse and hate crimes all because of my heritage, it's no wonder I feel like a stranger in my own land. Because of these painful experiences I know what it is like to be treated like an outcast, but I refuse to let that experience have the final word.
My family history is an ethnic mix of Palestinian, Russian, Israeli, and Pakistani heritage. This kind of family couldn't have happened anywhere else in the world. I am who I am because of my ancestor's ability to immigrate to the United States. The immigrant experience is what makes me feel distinctively American, despite those who try to tell me otherwise.
Sometimes amid the din of hurtful rhetoric sprinkled with words like "illegal" and harsh tones that make "immigrant" sound like a curse word, we forget that we had a distant aunt from Ireland who in the 1850's was once hated for being Catholic in America. We don't realize that our Japanese neighbor was once held in a WW II detention camp, and entirely forget that our Native American ancestors were persecuted and made into immigrants on their own land. Too many of us simply aren't connected to our immigrant past.
I don't ever want to hide my identity, nor do I want any immigrant to have to hide theirs. I am a proud Muslim American that loves the diversity and opportunity of this country. A friend, Naglaa, pursues a PHD from GWU and comes from an Egyptian village hailing from an illiterate mother and father. Their incredible bravery and trust in America is inspiring and the great smile that graces her face despite her hardships is humbling. The Prophet Muhammad [peace be upon him] said, "Even a smile is charity." My friend has inspired me to smile and keep an open heart so that I may learn from other's stories, and remember that what connects us most is simply being human.
It is time that Americans reclaim the word "immigrant", rejoicing in it as the common identity of most all Americans. In response to the current national debate around immigration, I am working with the Interfaith Youth Core's "Stranger to Neighbor" project to start an interfaith project documenting and sharing immigrant stories through video, poetry, art and pictures. It is my hope that through the sharing of stories we will bring an end to the dehumanizing language around immigration, and reconnect us all to the immigrant experience.
The content of this blog reflects the views of its author and does not necessarily reflect the views of either Eboo Patel or the Interfaith Youth Core.
By
Eboo Patel
|
June 1, 2010; 5:54 PM ET
Save & Share:
Previous: The Dalai Lama on interfaith cooperation |
Next: To the Class of 2010
Posted by: dianazulyetti | June 16, 2010 12:04 AM
Report Offensive Comment
Thank you for the information, its great!
Visit me too at @ http://www.unand.ac.id/arsipua/datastaff/
Trimakasih^^
Posted by: dianazulyetti | June 16, 2010 12:02 AM
Report Offensive Comment
What is a Muslim American? No one cares about your religion. So drop "Muslim" we really don't care. What is a British Muslim? or a Dutch Muslim or a German Muslim? as long as you keep the Muslim title you will tend to say "Proud" with it. What are you proud of?
Posted by: Arif2 | June 3, 2010 10:01 PM
Report Offensive Comment
I have no desire to reclaim my "identity as an immigrant".
My great-grandfather on my father's side was an immigrant; my mother's side was here for the American Revolution. I, however, am NOT an Irish immigrant or a Dutch immigrant. I am an American, which is exactly how any legal immigrant to this country should view themselves. The "old country" should be viewed as exactly that.
Posted by: EddietheInfidel | June 3, 2010 7:49 PM
Report Offensive Comment
It is time that Americans reclaim the word "immigrant", rejoicing in it as the common identity of most all Americans.
---------------------------------------------
Excellent idea.
We should call the illegal ones "interlopers" to distinguish them from the ones who played by the rules and earned their way in for their ability to contribute to our society.
Posted by: WmarkW | June 3, 2010 8:53 AM
Report Offensive Comment
Well said by Akafir:
You write: "I don't ever want to hide my identity, nor do I want any immigrant to have to hide theirs. I am a proud Muslim American that loves the diversity and opportunity of this country."
Of all the various different "identities" that you had, you chose to pigeon hole yourself into a "Proud Muslim". You should take the time to read Amartya Sen "Identity and Violence". Sen observes that ideologies of hate typically slot people into communities based on a single dimension that trumps the multifaceted affinities of class, sex, politics and personal interest that make up individual identities. With your multi cultral background, being an "American" free to be who ever or what ever one chooses was not good enough for you. It had to be a "Proud Muslim". How Islamic!! The claptrap about immigration is merely a side issue isn't it? You are shilling for unquestioning acceptability of Islam. This is America and you are free to be proud of being a Muslim, but that freedom requires that others are free to examine your Islam and reject it. It is a violent ideology, and for many you merely show your ignorance when you express pride in being a follower of Muhammad.
POSTED BY: AKAFIR | JUNE 2, 2010 4:12 PM
Posted by: clearthinking1 | June 3, 2010 4:25 AM
Report Offensive Comment
As a brown Iranian Jewish woman, I certainly
understand discrimination and hatred in America, and reclaiming the word "immigrant" is a good idea.
Every semester, I teach a section of ESL at a high advanced level. Most of my students are very well educated, very smart. Recently, I brought to class a well-known American-born writer to speak of her own struggles writing in French.
As the discussion went on and she continually used the word "immigrant" in reference to her own experience, the frowns of the students suddenly relaxed. One asked, in mild bewilderment, "Do you see being an immigrant as positive (add italics)?"
"Why, yes," she answered, equally puzzled.
Posted by: farnaz_mansouri2 | June 2, 2010 9:38 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Ilana Alazzeh,
"It is time that Americans reclaim the word "immigrant",..."
Americans do not need to reclaim the word "immigrant"; Americans have never abandoned or forfeited the word "immigrant".
It is time, however, that people stop sneaking into this country, and other countries, illegally.
That is the problem, not immigration.
Posted by: PSolus | June 2, 2010 5:25 PM
Report Offensive Comment
It took me a little time to understand!!
You write: "I don't ever want to hide my identity, nor do I want any immigrant to have to hide theirs. I am a proud Muslim American that loves the diversity and opportunity of this country."
Of all the various different "identities" that you had, you chose to pigeon hole yourself into a "Proud Muslim". You should take the time to read Amartya Sen "Identity and Violence". Sen observes that ideologies of hate typically slot people into communities based on a single dimension that trumps the multifaceted affinities of class, sex, politics and personal interest that make up individual identities. With your multi cultral background, being an "American" free to be who ever or what ever one chooses was not good enough for you. It had to be a "Proud Muslim". How Islamic!! The claptrap about immigration is merely a side issue isn't it? You are shilling for unquestioning acceptability of Islam. This is America and you are free to be proud of being a Muslim, but that freedom requires that others are free to examine your Islam and reject it. It is a violent ideology, and for many you merely show your ignorance when you express pride in being a follower of Muhammad.
Posted by: AKafir | June 2, 2010 4:12 PM
Report Offensive Comment
According to the very nice Pakistani guy that I was talking to this morning, people all over the world still want to come to America because we treat people as equals. (Well, supposedly.) They're not here because the "streets are paved with gold" the way that my great-grandparents and grandparents believed. They're not here to "take our jobs". They're still coming to America because they believe that everyone here is treated equally.
That's his words, not mine. But, I believe them.
Posted by: Athena4 | June 2, 2010 3:36 PM
Report Offensive Comment
test
Posted by: David Waters | June 2, 2010 1:55 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Is Ed Koch "dehumanizing" immigrants when he points out that 70% of Americans oppose amnesty for illegal immigrants? Americans do not discriminate or oppose legal immigration.
Posted by: AKafir | June 2, 2010 1:35 PM
Report Offensive Comment
"we will bring an end to the dehumanizing language around immigration, and reconnect us all to the immigrant experience."
There is no dehumanizing language around immigration. I am an immigrant. You are not. You were born in California. Perhaps you like Eboo want to play the victim and try to find "dehumanization" from those who disagree with you.
There is an issue of legal versus illegal immigration. People are trying to deal with why the US government is incapable of enforcing or even implementing immigration laws. Are the present immigration laws flawed that they cannot be enforced, or is our politics so fractured that we can no longer have a viable immigration policy.
Posted by: AKafir | June 2, 2010 1:26 PM
Report Offensive Comment
The comments to this entry are closed.

Twitter










Thank you for the information, its great!
Visit me too at @ http://www.unand.ac.id/arsipua/datastaff/
Trimakasih^^