THE QUESTION
If some religious people believe they have a monopoly on truth, then are conversation and common ground possible? If so, what would be the difficulties and benefits of such a conversation?
Posted by Hal Straus on November 10, 2006 8:34 AM
FROM THE PANEL
"On Faith" panelist Elaine Pagels is Harrington Spear Paine Foundation Professor of Religion at Princeton University and author of best-selling books about the pluralistic nature of early Christianity. Her book Beyond Belief: The Secret Gospel of Thomas (2003), which was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize, focuses on religious claims to possessing the ultimate truth. Pagels' The Gnostic Gospels (1979), an analysis of 52 early Christian manuscripts unearthed in Egypt and known as the Nag Hammadi Library. The book was chosen by the Modern Library as one of the 100 best books of the 20th Century. She also authored The Origin of Satan (1995), and Adam, Eve and the Serpent (1988). Pagels was awarded Rockefeller, Guggenheim and MacArthur Fellowships in three consecutive years. Her next work, Reading Judas: The Gospel of Judas and the Shaping of Christianity, is co-authored with Karen King and set to be published in the spring of 2007. She is on leave from Princeton for the academic year 2006-2007 while a visiting scholar at the Russell Sage Foundation in New York.
Questions To Answer Before A Conversation
What we need to ask is what pressures generated each tradition's claims to monopoly, against whom such claims were made, and what is at stake in making them.
Elaine Pagels Best-selling author and Pulitzer Prize nominee |Nov 20, 2006 at 12:00 PM
The Reverend William J. Byron, S.J., a former president of Catholic University, is on leave this year from his position as research professor at the Sellinger School of Business and Management, Loyola College in Maryland to serve as president of St. Joseph's Preparatory School in Philadelphia. The “On Faith” panelist served as interim president of Loyola University , New Orleans in 2003-04 and for three years prior to that, was pastor of Holy Trinity Catholic Church in Washington , D.C. From 1992 to 2000, he taught "Social Responsibilities of Business" at Georgetown University , where he was Distinguished Professor of the Practice of Ethics and served as rector of the Georgetown Jesuit Community. He was president of Catholic University for a decade (1982-92). Byron writes a syndicated bi-weekly column, Looking Around , for Catholic News Service, and is the author of a dozen books, including A Book of Quiet Prayer (2006); The Power of Principles: Ethics in the New Corporate Culture (2006) and Answers from Within: Spiritual Guidelines for Managing Setbacks in Work and Life (1998) . A founding director and past chairman of Bread for the World , Byron was also named the 1999 recipient of the Association of Catholic Colleges and Universities' Theodore M. Hesburgh Award for his contributions to the advancement of Catholic higher education. In that same year, he received the Council of Independent Colleges' Academic Leadership Award. Byron, who holds a doctorate in economics as well as theology degrees, served in the U.S. Army's 508 th Parachute Infantry Regiment before entering the Jesuit order in 1950. He was ordained a priest in 1961.
Reasoned Argument
William J. Byron Columnist and former president, Catholic University |"On Faith" panelist and rock musician Salman Ahmad founded the popular South Asian band Junoon . The group has sold over 25 million albums and in 2001 became the first rock band invited to perform at the U.N. General Assembly. Ahmad also was appointed U.N. Goodwill Ambassador for HIV/AIDS. He personalized the "I Care, Do You?" U.N. poster campaign in Pakistan by taking the well-known verse of the Koran about reverence for human life and paraphrasing it to say: "Saving one life (from AIDS) is like saving the whole of humanity." Born in Pakistan , Ahmad grew up in New York . He obtained his medical degree from Pakistan 's King Edward Medical college in Lahore . He helped form Pakistan 's first pop band, Vital Signs , whose debut album sold a million copies. Ahmad decided to give up his stethoscope and pick up his guitar, and after leaving Vital Signs in 1990 he founded Junoon. Recently Ahmad appeared in two documentary films: It's My Country Too , about Muslim-Americans, and Rockstar and the Mullahs . Both were broadcast worldwide on PBS and the BBC. A passionate activist in promoting peace between India and Pakistan , Ahmad made a song/video Ghoom Tana . It is on his latest solo album INFINITI.
Grapes By Any Other Name
Salman Ahmad Founder, Junoon |Sherman A. Jackson is a professor of Arabic and Islamic Studies, a visiting professor of law, and a professor of Afro-American Studies at the University of Michigan , Ann Arbor . He has served as Executive Director for the Center of Arabic Study Abroad (CASA) in Cairo , Egypt , is a member of the U.S.-Muslim World Advisory Committee of the U.S. Institute of Peace , and a co-founder of the American Learning Institute for Muslims (ALIM). The “On Faith” panelist is also a former member of the Fiqh Council of North America , past president of the Sharî‘ah Scholars' Association of North America (SSANA) and a past trustee of the North American Islamic Trust (NAIT).
In addition to numerous articles on Islamic law, theology and history, Jackson is the author of Islamic Law and the State: The Constitutional Jurisprudence of Shihâb al-Dîn al-Qarâfî , On the Boundaries of Theological Tolerance in Islam: Abû Hâmid al-Ghazâlî's Faysal al-Tafriqa and, most recently, the controversial Islam and Blackamerican: Looking Towards the Third Resurrection . Jackson has lectured throughout the US and in numerous countries abroad. He has also taught at the University of Texas at Austin , Indiana University, Wayne State University and was recently offered a full-professorship at Stanford University , which he declined.
Is Common Ground The Solution or the Problem?
Sherman Jackson Co-founder, American Learning Institute for Muslims |READER RESPONSE
» Stan | We need to back up to the beginning. Humans apparently won't tolerate there being no god. Thence, they want the Bible and the other writings to be tr...
» TheArchon | Which religion does NOT claim to have a monopoly on "truth"? Religious beliefs are based on faith, not facts, and you can't disprove faith.
It wor...
» Human being | Conversation, as defined by Martin Buber, can have a common ground as result, if it is a "dialogue" the participants strive to have. A dialogue has to...
Active Conversations
- Is Religion Man-Made? (582 comments)
- Can There Be Common Ground? (986 comments)
- Shariah Law in the West (176 comments)
- Discrimination Against Catholics (309 comments)
- Islam and Violence (1581 comments)
Categories
Guest Voices Archive

» Vernon Jordan: Black Americans have a spiritual as well as a secular faith in America.
» Ayaan Hirsi Ali» Hamza Yusuf
» Christopher Hitchens
» T.D. Jakes
» Brad Hirschfield
» Timothy Shriver
» Irshad Manji
» Nora Gallagher
» Jimmy Carter
» The Dalai Lama
» Michael Gerson
» Full Archive
Links & Resources
- VIDEO: DIVINE IMPULSES with Sally Quinn » Desmond Tutu
- VIDEO: FINDING FAITH by Christy McKerney
- GEORGETOWN/ON FAITH
- THE GOD VOTE by Jacques Berlinerblau
- FAITH IN ACTION by Katherine Marshall
- THE FAITH DIVIDE by Eboo Patel
- UNDER GOD by Claire Hoffman
- RELIGION FROM THE HEART by Timothy Shriver
- FAITHBOOK
- PRAYING FIELDS by Kathy Orton
- NEWSWEEK: Belief Watch by Lisa Miller

